Skip to main content

Discipline and Grandchildren

While my daughter is away at college, I am the primary caregiver for her two-year-old son. This means I am responsible for everything involving his life---including discipline.

Just like my daughter did when she was little, my grandson constantly tests his boundries to see how much he can get away with. I am a firm believer that children need limits and boundaries. They also need to understand there are consequences for bad behavior.

The challenge lies in making sure parents and grandparents are on one accord when it comes to discipline. For example, if a parent does not believe in spanking and you, as a grandparent do believe in spanking, how do you handle that? I personally agree with an article I read on the grandparents.com website, which indicates the guardian who has home-field advantage has the rights over discipline.

So what do you say? Do grandparents have rights when it comes to discipline? Or should they simply adhere to the "time-out" policy and leave the real punishment to the parent(s)?

Comments

Melodieann said…
Speaking from experience, grandparents should definitely have the right to discipline as they see fit. My daughter admittedly has a problem getting her own daughter to mind. But at my house it's a different story. Morgan knows that grandma will not put with the same nonsense Mom does. I think it helps her to see that she will have limits, even if Mom and Dad don't always set them.
Beverly Mahone said…
Melodieann,

My daughter also seems to have a tough time laying down the law with her son. That's why they always seem like two kid playing together---while mean old grandma has to discipline BOTH of them!
Kathy Wulff said…
My paternal grandparents lived nearby so we spent a lot of time with them growing up and believe me, they disciplined us like we were their own children! No nonsense in their house!

Of course, my parents weren't shy about whacking us now and again, so there wasn't any conflict between my parents and my grandparents when it came to disciplining us.
Susan Adcox said…
I agree that grandparents should be able to discipline grandchildren when in their care, but only according to the parents' boundaries. If parents say no spanking, grandparents must abide by that. My children don't discipline by spanking, and I have no problem with that.

It's been my experience that grandchildren aren't much of a discipline problem when they just come to visit. Grandparents tend to give them almost complete attention, and they are usually angelic. It's when they come to stay for days at a time that it gets hairy because Grandma and Grandpa have things they have to get done. I'd suggest that before extended visits, grandparents get some advice from the parents about what discipline techniques work best. If the parents are hopeless at discipline, I'd do some reading and come up with some strategies on my own.
Pat Montgomery said…
Here's the deal. If my kids want me to babysit, it is my rules. They all know I was not abusive to them, but there were limits and consequences. And there are for my grandchildren when they are in my care. I did discuss it with the kids first. Now, if my kids are present and the child does something that requires correction, I leave it to the parents. Sometimes I walk away with a bloody tongue from biting it. But I love your quote about "home field advantage"!!
Beverly Mahone said…
Susan,

Asking your children how they discipline their own kids is a good idea, however, I believe children test their parents differently than they do their grandparents so I'm not sure if the same manner of discipline would work for both sides.
Eileen Williams said…
Not being fortunate enough to have grandchildren of my own, I'm weighing in on this as an outsider. However, it does seem to me that the person who has accepted the majority of the responsibility (at this point, you) should be the one to establish the rules of discipline. However, I can guess that this is a complicated matter and one that has varying opinions.
Pam Archer said…
I believe that a grandparent should discipline a grandchild, while they are in one's watchcare. The methods used should be in accordance to the parents' wishes, however when the parent is still a child, some guidance as to why and how one should discipline is advisable.
BluePixo said…
Children need a clear definition of acceptable and unacceptable conduct. They feel more secure when they know the borders of permissible action.

*BluePixo Entertainment - A place for mom and dad to share topics about parenthood*

Popular posts from this blog

This Survey Stinks for Baby Boomers

The majority of baby boomers do not wash their underwear enough!  That's what an online survey by Mulberry Cleaners revealed recently.  The results were published in Reader's Digest.

I have to admit I was very surprised to read the results, which indicated 16 percent of middle-aged folks reported NEVER washing their underwear.  Now, 16 percent may not sound like a large number but that's still 16 percent too many, in comparison to 85 percent of millennials who said they toss their undergarments in the laundry after one or two wears.  Only 10.3 percent of millennial women said they never washed theirs, which might make sense if these young women had parents who were enablers and never taught them to do much of anything, especially how to wash clothes.

When it comes to washing bed sheets, 43 percent of women said they wash them every week, compared to seven percent of men who said they had washed their sheets only once in six months.  But even worse than that is the fact th…

18 Years

During a recent trip to my doctor's office for my annual health check-up, I got news I'm not sure I thought I would ever hear.  "You can stop taking your carvedilol."  I'd been taking this medication for congestive heart failure.

My story of having congestive heart failure began 18 years ago around 2:30 in the morning.  I was lying in bed trying to sleep but I was having trouble breathing.  I was gasping for air.  I leaned over to my husband (ex) and told him how I was feeling and asked him to take me to the hospital.  He didn't move so I drove myself to the ER and ended up being admitted, where I stayed for 10 days.  Not only did I have to worry about getting better but I also had to be concerned about my 10-year-old daughter's welfare since she was now in the sole custody of her father, who was absent from the family more times than he was present.

Little did I know at the time just how sick I was.  I was already being treated for hyperthyroidism but th…

Survey says Christmas is about the Experience not the Gifts

If there's a survey out somewhere, you can believe I'll find it and share it----like this one on what Americans say they want for Christmas.

E-X-P-E-R-I-E-N-C-E!  Yes, according to a report released by IfOnly, an overwhelming 81 percent of respondents said they preferred an "experience" over any other type of gift.  

Okay, so the next question is, what kind of experience?  

39 percent said go on a helicopter tour
32 percent said go on a private tour of a museum
27 percent said pet a panda at the zoo

But get this:  36 percent of those who took the survey said they would rather spend the holiday with a wild animal than with their in-laws.

75 percent of Millennials said they would do anything in exchange for an incredible experience while nearly half of those surveyed said they would give up an hour of sleep for the entire holiday season to have an incredible experience instead of receiving a gift certificate.

And for those of you who have been complaining about lack of intimac…